PhishFence vs Valimail

Enterprise DMARC with managed-service depth.

Valimail is the enterprise / Fortune 500 incumbent in this space. They offer fully managed DMARC enforcement, professional services, and integrations with major identity providers. PhishFence is positioned for SMB / mid-market and indie operators: self-serve, transparent pricing, no professional-services dependency. If you need a managed service or Fortune 500 procurement compatibility, Valimail. If you want to handle DMARC yourself with strong tooling, PhishFence.

Feature matrix

Last refreshed 2026-05-11. Sources: each vendor's public pricing + features pages.

Feature PhishFence Valimail
DMARC aggregate report ingestion ✓ ✓
DMARC enforcement wizard ✓ ✓
Managed enforcement (vendor moves you to p=reject) — ✓
Identity-provider integrations (Okta, Azure AD) — ✓
Lookalike domain monitoring ✓ ✓
Subdomain takeover detection ✓ —
CT log monitoring ✓ —
LLM root-cause analysis ✓ —
MCP server ✓ —
Self-serve signup ✓ —
Public pricing ✓ —
PCI DSS 4.0 / SOC 2 evidence pack ✓ ✓
Free plan ✓ —

Pricing positioning

Valimail does not publish pricing; expect $20K+/yr per domain for the managed offering. PhishFence Starter is $49/mo (3 domains), Business is $249/mo (50 domains). For most organisations under Fortune 1000 the price gap is roughly 20-50x. Where Valimail's professional services and procurement compatibility are required, PhishFence is not a fit.

Valimail's public pricing → · PhishFence pricing →

Try PhishFence free

Sign up, monitor one domain forever, no credit card required. If we're not the right fit you're not out anything.

Start free

PhishFence is not affiliated with Valimail. Comparison content based on public information and good-faith review of each vendor's documentation. If you spot something inaccurate, let us know and we'll correct it.